Jul 13, 2025
MLB Player Props Today: Sunday's Top Plays Include Isiah Kiner-Falefa [7/13/2025]
Read Article Blue Jays vs. Yankees Prediction for MLB Tuesday [9/19/2023]
Updated: | First published:
Written by Dimers Data
![Blue Jays vs. Yankees Prediction for MLB Tuesday [9/19/2023]](https://imgix.cosmicjs.com/e217b3b0-a651-11ee-aa4c-49034c903d7e-9e8e54b336028795dc800ffe1d352da7.jpg?w=750)
The New York Yankees will face the Toronto Blue Jays in MLB action at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday, starting at 7:05PM ET.
Clarke Schmidt (9-8, 4.56 ERA) will start for the Yankees, pitting him against Yusei Kikuchi (9-6, 3.81 ERA) for the Blue Jays.
Dimers' best betting picks for Blue Jays vs. Yankees, plus game predictions and best odds, are detailed below.
First Bet Offer with BetMGM
Bet up to $1,000
Get it back in bonuses if you lose
Who Will Win: Blue Jays vs. Yankees
Using cutting-edge machine learning and data, Dimers.com has simulated Tuesday's Blue Jays-Yankees MLB game 10,000 times.
Dimers' renowned predictive analytics model, DimersBOT, gives the Yankees a 53% chance of defeating the Blue Jays.
More: Blue Jays vs. Yankees Simulated 10,000 Times
Blue Jays vs. Yankees Odds [9/19]
- Run Line: Yankees +1.5 (-200), Blue Jays -1.5 (+165)
- Moneyline: Yankees -115, Blue Jays +100
- Total: Over/Under 7.5 (-118/+100)
The Yankees are +1.5 underdogs against the Blue Jays, with -200 at BetMGM the best odds currently available.
For the favored Blue Jays (-1.5) to cover the run line, BetMGM also has the best odds currently on offer at +165.
PointsBet currently has the best moneyline odds for the Yankees at -115, which means you can risk $115 to win $100, for a total payout of $215, if they get the W.
Elsewhere, FanDuel Sportsbook currently has the best moneyline odds for the Blue Jays at +100, where you can risk $100 to win $100, for a total payout of $200, if they come out on top.
The Over/Under for total runs scored sits at 7.5 with FanDuel Sportsbook, which currently has the best odds for the Over at -118, while PointsBet currently has the best odds for the Under at +100.
As always, check out the sportsbooks you have access to in your state for the best MLB odds and lines.
According to DimersBOT, the Yankees (+1.5) have a 65% chance of covering the run line, while the 7.5-run Over/Under has a 60% chance of going Over.
More: Best Bets for Every MLB Game
Best Bets: Blue Jays vs. Yankees
- Run Line: Yankees +1.5 @ -200 via BetMGM (65% probability)
- Moneyline: Yankees @ -115 via PointsBet (53% probability)
- Total: Over 7.5 @ -118 via FanDuel Sportsbook (60% probability) 🔥
When you see a 🔥, that means you've found one of Dimers' best bets of the day across all major pro and college sports.
Dimers' best bets are based on world-class simulations and betting intelligence to serve you the best possible plays every day of the year.
Blue Jays vs. Yankees Prediction
Dimers.com predicts that the Yankees are more likely to defeat the Blue Jays at Yankee Stadium on Tuesday.
This prediction is backed by comprehensive data-driven analysis, with the Yankees having a 53% chance of winning after conducting 10,000 game simulations.
Click or tap on See Matchup to find out more.
Pre-Game Probabilities
Last Updated: 11:32PM, Sep 19
Moneyline
Over / Under
Run Line
Yusei Kikuchi 9-6, 3.81 ERA
Clarke Schmidt 9-8, 4.56 ERA
Get the best bets with Dimers Pro
Dimers has full betting coverage of Tuesday's Blue Jays-Yankees game, including pregame predictions, computer picks, and live win probabilities.
Remember, DimersBOT updates often, so check this article for the latest betting insights before Blue Jays vs. Yankees on Tuesday September 19, 2023.
Blue Jays vs. Yankees 2023
Tuesday's MLB matchup between the Yankees and Blue Jays at Yankee Stadium is scheduled to commence at 7:05PM ET.
- Who: Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees
- Date: Tuesday September 19, 2023
- Time: 7:05PM ET / 4:05PM PT
- Venue: Yankee Stadium
Want to join an online sportsbook and start betting on MLB now? We've got access to the best available sign-up offers in every legal betting state.
Best Sportsbook Promotions
Why Join Multiple Sportsbooks?
Swipe across to view more offers 
Exclusive
$1500 in Bonus Bets Paid Back if you Don't Win!
T&C's apply.
How to claim
MOST POPULAR
Sign up With Code DIMERS to Unlock $150 in Bonus Bets When you Bet $5! Win or Lose!
T&C's apply.
How to claim
HOTTEST
Bet $10 Get $100 in Bonus Bets
T&C's apply.
How to claim
MOST POPULAR
Bet $5, Get $150 in Bonus Bets INSTANTLY!
T&C's apply.
How to claim
NEW PLAYERS
Bet $5 Get $150 in Bonus Bets If Your Bet Wins!
T&C's apply.
How to claim
TRENDING
New Customers Play FREE For Your Share Of Millions
T&C's apply.
How to claim
Calling Our Shot ⚾️ Best Bets
Calling Our Shot produces daily MLB betting content, including the latest best bets featured below.
Make Informed Sports Betting Decisions Today
Dimers' picks are based on 10,000 simulations per game, using reliable and up-to-date data sources and analytical methods.
While our Blue Jays vs. Yankees predictions can help you make informed decisions, it's vital that you gamble responsibly and manage your bankroll effectively.
For additional resources and advice on responsible gambling, please call 1-800-GAMBLER.
What MLB Games Are on Today?
Now you've got the 411 on Blue Jays vs. Yankees, get the best predictions for all MLB games via our MLB picks and predictions, where you can find probabilities and odds, as well as our best bets for each and every MLB matchup. Want a pick for the Run Line? You got it. How about the Over/Under? Yup, got that too. The Moneyline? Yes sir. And these picks are good, I mean REALLY good!
In addition to our leading MLB predictions, Dimers also offers the best MLB prop bets today, projecting home runs, RBIs, and more against the top odds available every day of the MLB season.
While you're here, Dimers' MLB Futures page is our in-house approach to revealing who will win the World Series, with our data-driven probabilities paired with the best odds on the market.
Written by
Dimers Data Dimers Data delivers cold-blooded analysis straight from thousands of simulations run by predictive models built by our in-house team of data scientists and analysts. No hunches. No guesswork. Just pure, data-led insight serious bettors rely on to stay ahead.
Advertiser disclosure
