May 19, 2026
White Sox vs. Mariners prediction: Seattle favored to win Tuesday's MLB matchup [5/19/2026]
Read Article Blue Jays vs. Yankees prediction: Yankees favored to win Tuesday's MLB matchup [5/19/2026]
Updated: | First published:
Written by Jason Bevilacqua, Head of Content and Communities
Get Toronto Blue Jays vs New York Yankees predictions for MLB Tuesday.
MLB action continues on Tuesday at 7:05 PM ET as the Toronto Blue Jays lock horns with the New York Yankees at Yankee Stadium.
The Yankees will have Will Warren (5-1, 3.42 ERA) as their starting pitcher, while the Blue Jays will counter with Dylan Cease (3-1, 2.41 ERA).
Based on updated simulation results, Dimers' proven MLB model projects the Yankees as the most likely winner of the Blue Jays vs. Yankees game.
This article offers further insights into Tuesday's matchup, including best bets and picks.
Blue Jays vs. Yankees prediction: Who will win and cover?
Using innovative machine learning and statistical analysis, we have simulated the outcome of Tuesday's MLB matchup between the Blue Jays and Yankees, forming part of our MLB predictions coverage.
Our famous predictive model gives the Yankees a 55% chance of defeating the Blue Jays.
According to our model, the Blue Jays (+1.5) have a 61% chance of covering the run line, while the 8.5-run over/under has a 58% chance of going over.
Blue Jays vs. Yankees odds [5/19/2026]
We have sourced the best MLB odds in America for this game, which are listed here:
| Bet Type | Blue Jays | Yankees |
|---|---|---|
| Run Line | +1.5 (-176) | -1.5 (+149) |
| Moneyline | +116 | -136 |
| Total | o8.5 (-120) | u8.5 (+100) |
All odds are correct at the time of publication and are subject to change.
Blue Jays vs. Yankees picks and best bet
After matching our predictions against the best current odds, we can reveal our picks for each of the major markets. Plus, find our best bet for the game below:
| Bet Type | Pick | Bet Now |
|---|---|---|
| Run Line | Yankees -1.5 | +149 |
| Moneyline | Blue Jays | +116 |
| Total | Over 8.5 | -120 |
According to our MLB best bets, the top play to make on this game is Over 8.5 total runs.
These picks are based on our probabilities matched against the implied probabilities from the sportsbook odds.
Blue Jays vs. Yankees game-day updates and essential details
Tuesday's MLB matchup between the Yankees and Blue Jays at Yankee Stadium is scheduled to commence at 7:05 PM ET.
- Who: Toronto Blue Jays vs. New York Yankees
- Date: Tuesday, May 19, 2026
- Time: 7:05 PM ET/4:05PM PT
- Venue: Yankee Stadium
Conclusion
We predict the Yankees, with a 55% win probability, will likely beat the Blue Jays in Tuesday's MLB matchup.
Additional tools and information for betting safely can be found in our Responsible Gambling hub.
Continue reading with Dimers Pro
Join now to unlock this article and get full access to our predictions and betting tools. Cancel anytime.
$0 for 3 days
then $14.99/week
Already a Pro member? Log in
New here? See everything Pro includes
Jason Bevilacqua, an expert in MLB, NHL, NBA, MLS, and NFL, delivers game previews, best bets, and props. Since 2020, as Head of Social and Community at Dimers, he has contributed insightful articles utilizing data-driven models and simulations.
Advertiser disclosure
