MLS betting tips: Saturday's picks include St Louis City vs. Colorado play [5/9/2026]

Colorado ML (+105)

• Edge: 9.0%
• Probability: 57.8%
• Matchup: St Louis City vs. Colorado (9:30PM ET, Saturday)

Our model has identified value on Colorado to defeat St Louis City at +105 odds. A 57.8% probability produces an edge of 9.0%, making this the strongest play for today's MLS slate.

Nashville ML (-160)

• Edge: 7.2%
• Probability: 68.7%
• Matchup: D.C. United vs. Nashville (9:15PM ET, Saturday)

Nashville ML carries a 7.2% edge and a probability of 68.7% at -160 odds, according to our model.

Charlotte ML (+110)

• Edge: 6.3%
• Probability: 53.9%
• Matchup: Cincinnati vs. Charlotte (7:30PM ET, Saturday)

Charlotte ML at +110 odds shows a 6.3% edge, supported by a 53.9% probability in simulations.

San Jose ML (+210)

• Edge: 4.7%
• Probability: 37%
• Matchup: Vancouver vs. San Jose (10:30PM ET, Saturday)

A 4.7% edge and 37% probability make San Jose at the moneyline at a value play in the Vancouver vs. San Jose matchup, per our model.

Orlando ML (+250)

• Edge: 3.2%
• Probability: 31.7%
• Matchup: Orlando vs. Montreal (4:30PM ET, Saturday)

Orlando ML at +250 odds presents a 3.2% edge, with simulations resulting in a probability of 31.7%.

Toronto ML (+280)

• Edge: 2.5%
• Probability: 28.8%
• Matchup: Miami vs. Toronto (1:00PM ET, Saturday)

Our model finds value on Toronto to win at +280 odds, supported by an edge of 2.5%.

MLS best bets summary: Saturday, 5/9/2026

As of 7:35AM ET, here are our top MLS bets by edge recommended by our model:

Matchup	Bet	Odds	Edge	Probability
St Louis City vs. Colorado	Colorado ML	+105 @ FanDuel	9.0%	57.8%
D.C. United vs. Nashville	Nashville ML	-160 @ BetMGM	7.2%	68.7%
Cincinnati vs. Charlotte	Charlotte ML	+110 @ BetMGM	6.3%	53.9%
Vancouver vs. San Jose	San Jose ML	+210 @ FanDuel	4.7%	37%
Orlando vs. Montreal	Orlando ML	+250 @ BetMGM	3.2%	31.7%
Miami vs. Toronto	Toronto ML	+280 @ FanDuel	2.5%	28.8%

List of upcoming MLS games to bet on [5/9/2026]

• Miami vs. Toronto (1:00PM ET, Saturday)
• NY Red Bulls vs. Chicago (2:30PM ET, Saturday)
• Orlando vs. Montreal (4:30PM ET, Saturday)
• LA Galaxy vs. Atlanta (7:30PM ET, Saturday)
• Cincinnati vs. Charlotte (7:30PM ET, Saturday)
• Philadelphia vs. New England (7:30PM ET, Saturday)
• Salt Lake vs. Dallas (8:30PM ET, Saturday)
• D.C. United vs. Nashville (9:15PM ET, Saturday)
• St Louis City vs. Colorado (9:30PM ET, Saturday)
• San Diego FC vs. Seattle (10:30PM ET, Saturday)
• Sporting KC vs. Portland (10:30PM ET, Saturday)
• Vancouver vs. San Jose (10:30PM ET, Saturday)

Conclusion

Our MLS best bets are locked and loaded for May 9, 2026, featuring plays such as Colorado ML and Nashville ML. Powered by advanced simulations, these picks are here to boost your betting game.

Our predictions are drawn from current data to help you make informed decisions. For additional resources and advice, head to our Responsible Gambling hub.

All odds and probabilities in this article are correct and accurate at the time of publication.