MLB Player Props Today: Monday's Top Plays Include David Peterson [5/12/2025]

MLB prop betting is back for Monday, May 12, 2025, with our baseball player props generated through ground-breaking simulations and innovative machine learning techniques.

These insights are here to elevate your betting strategy for a thrilling day of MLB action, featuring players such as David Peterson, Paul Skenes and Brett Baty.

Our next three +EV prop betting opportunities are listed below, with Dimers Pro subscribers receiving unlimited access to our full suite of prop picks, including the top MLB prop of the day.

Today's full list of MLB prop bets is led by a player in the Red Sox vs. Tigers game to go over his outs recorded line, with our in-house predictive model pinpointing an edge of 14% at +135 odds.

Join Dimers Pro now to unlock this and more data-driven props and best bets.

Get 20% off Dimers Pro With Code 20BASEBALL

Start My Free Trial

List of MLB Prop Bets for Monday

Monday's MLB prop betting action begins with the Pirates vs. Mets game at 7:10PM ET. These prop picks are sorted by game start time, with the highest edges and probabilities reserved exclusively for Dimers Pro users.

David Peterson Over 2.5 Earned Runs (+120)

• Probability: 51.0%
• Edge: 5.6%
• Game: Pirates vs. Mets (7:10PM ET)

Our model has flagged a strong MLB prop bet for Monday's Pirates vs. Mets matchup, focusing on NY Mets' David Peterson. We suggest betting on David Peterson Over 2.5 Earned Runs with an edge of 5.6% at +120 odds.

David Peterson Over 2.5 Earned Runs

+120

Bet $20
Payout $44Bet $20, Payout $44

Paul Skenes Under 1.5 Earned Runs (+115)

• Probability: 56.7%
• Edge: 10.2%
• Game: Pirates vs. Mets (7:10PM ET)

Our model has discovered another +EV prop bet for Monday's MLB action, with Pittsburgh's Paul Skenes in our sights in the Pirates-Mets game. We recommend betting on Paul Skenes Under 1.5 Earned Runs with an edge of 10.2% at +115 odds.

Paul Skenes Under 1.5 Earned Runs

+115

Bet $20
Payout $43Bet $20, Payout $43

David Peterson Over 5.5 Hits Allowed (+120)

• Probability: 53.4%
• Edge: 7.9%
• Game: Pirates vs. Mets (7:10PM ET)

According to our analysis, the next player prop bet for today's MLB action focuses on NY Mets' David Peterson in the Pirates vs. Mets matchup. The recommended bet is David Peterson Over 5.5 Hits Allowed, offering an edge of 7.9% at +120 odds.

David Peterson Over 5.5 Hits Allowed

+120

Bet $20
Payout $44Bet $20, Payout $44

MLB Player Prop Picks: Monday, May 12, 2025

A quick summary of our model's next three prop bets as of 7:56PM ET:

Get unlimited access to our complete suite of prop picks by signing up for Dimers Pro. Monday's MLB props are highlighted by a play with an edge of 14% on the best available odds.

Unlock 107 MLB Prop Picks Available Today

Start My Free Trial

More on MLB

The prop bets on this page are part of our MLB player props and MLB best bets series.

Stay updated with the latest MLB betting news, data-driven MLB predictions, MLB betting trends and World Series odds.

Conclusion

For May 12, 2025, our MLB prop bets are locked and loaded, featuring players like David Peterson, Paul Skenes and Brett Baty. Backed by the latest data and advanced simulations, these picks are here to give your betting strategy the edge it needs.

With the help of AI and automation, this article delivers today's MLB prop bets and insights quickly and accurately, while human oversight ensures high editorial quality. Our predictions are based on the latest data to help you make informed decisions.

For additional resources and advice on responsible gambling, please call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Note: Clicking links to our sportsbook partners may earn us a referral fee. Learn about how we review products and services.