College football player props today: Week 2 Saturday best props include Lucky Sutton [9/12/2026]

Dimers' college football player props are live for Saturday, September 12, 2026, with Lucky Sutton, Nate Frazier and Roman Gagliano among the best CFB player props today.

Our in-house college football player props model analyzes player projections and available odds across the FBS to look for betting value, with each pick backed by 20,000 Monte Carlo simulations.

List of college football prop bets for Week 2

Sourced from 325+ total college football props on site today, below are the top 10 college football player props for September 12, ranked by probability.

Lucky Sutton anytime touchdown scorer (-175)

• Edge: 7.0%
• Probability: 70.7%
• Game: San Diego State vs. UCLA (7:15PM ET)

Our model has flagged value on San Diego State's Lucky Sutton scoring an anytime touchdown. A probability of 70.7% gives this play an edge of 7.0% at -175 odds.

Nate Frazier to score 2+ touchdowns (+120)

• Edge: 5.5%
• Probability: 51.0%
• Game: Western Kentucky vs. Georgia (12:45PM ET)

Nate Frazier’s 2+ touchdowns prop shows a 51.0% probability and an 5.5% edge at +120 odds, according to our model.

Roman Gagliano anytime touchdown scorer (+145)

• Edge: 5.5%
• Probability: 46.4%
• Game: Middle Tennessee vs. Marshall (7:00PM ET)

The data highlights value on Roman Gagliano anytime touchdown scorer, with simulations showing a 46.4% probability and a 5.5% edge at +145.

Toby Payne anytime touchdown scorer (+185)

• Edge: 10.9%
• Probability: 46.0%
• Game: Middle Tennessee vs. Marshall (7:00PM ET)

Our model finds value on Toby Payne to score a touchdown, with a 46.0% probability and an edge of 10.9% at +185 odds.

Cam'ron Lacy anytime touchdown scorer (+275)

• Edge: 11.2%
• Probability: 37.9%
• Game: Middle Tennessee vs. Marshall (7:00PM ET)

Simulations indicate value on Cam'ron Lacy as an anytime touchdown scorer for Middle Tennessee, showing an edge of 11.2% at +275 odds.

DJ Vonnahme anytime touchdown scorer (+320)

• Edge: 13.4%
• Probability: 37.2%
• Game: Iowa State vs. Iowa (7:30PM ET)

DJ Vonnahme’s anytime touchdown scorer prop shows an edge of 13.4% at +320 odds, supported by a 37.2% probability according to our model.

Jaden Miller anytime touchdown scorer (+500)

• Edge: 18.8%
• Probability: 35.5%
• Game: Louisiana Tech vs. LSU (7:30PM ET)

Our model highlights value on Jaden Miller anytime touchdown scorer for Louisiana Tech, with a 35.5% probability and a 18.8% edge at +500 odds.

Legend Glasker anytime touchdown scorer (+200)

• Edge: 1.7%
• Probability: 35.0%
• Game: Arizona vs. Brigham Young (3:30PM ET)

The data shows value on Legend Glasker anytime touchdown scorer, supported by a 35.0% probability at +200 odds and an edge of 1.7%.

Chris Marshall anytime touchdown scorer (+210)

• Edge: 1.2%
• Probability: 33.5%
• Game: Arkansas vs. Utah (10:15PM ET)

A 1.2% edge on the anytime touchdown line makes Chris Marshall a value play in Arkansas vs. Utah, supported by a 33.5% probability at +210 odds.

DeJuan Williams score 2+ touchdowns (+330)

• Edge: 10.1%
• Probability: 33.4%
• Game: Maryland vs. Connecticut (3:30PM ET)

Simulations show value on DeJuan Williams score 2+ touchdowns here, with a 33.4% probability and 10.1% edge at +330 odds.

College Football player prop summary: Week 2, 2026

A quick summary of today’s top props by probability according to our model as of 8:27AM ET:

More college football betting

For further insights into this week's NCAAF action, check out the latest from the Dimers Sports Betting Podcast:

College football promo for Week 2

Make the most of today's player props—including Lucky Sutton anytime touchdown scorer—with theBet365 Sportsbook offer below:

Conclusion

For September 12, 2026, our college football prop bets feature players such as Lucky Sutton, Nate Frazier and Roman Gagliano. Each pick is grounded in real-time data and advanced simulations to help you bet with clarity and purpose.

Built using automation and human oversight, this article draws on the latest data to deliver accurate, timely insights. If using this article for betting, Dimers encourages responsible gambling.