MLB player props today: Wednesday's best props include Gerrit Cole [9/23/2026]
Get MLB player props today with projections for Wednesday's games.

Dimers' MLB player props are live for September 23, 2026, with today's top prop bets led by the likes of Gerrit Cole, George Kirby and Jesús Sánchez.
Our MLB player props model runs continuously to analyze every matchup—including Angels vs. Athletics and Reds vs. Braves—and surface the best MLB player prop bets across the market.
List of MLB prop bets for Wednesday, 9/23
Sourced from 185+ total MLB props on site today, below are the top 10 MLB player props for September 23, ranked by probability.
Gerrit Cole over 0.5 walks allowed (-229)
- Edge: 8.2%
- Probability: 77.8%
- Game: Rays vs. Yankees (7:05PM ET)
Our model has flagged value on Yankees' Gerrit Cole over 0.5 walks allowed. A probability of 77.8% gives this play an edge of 8.2% at -229 odds.
George Kirby under 1.5 walks allowed (-174)
- Edge: 9.1%
- Probability: 72.6%
- Game: Astros vs. Mariners (10:10PM ET)
George Kirby’s walks allowed prop shows a 72.6% probability and an 9.1% edge at -174 odds, according to our model.
Jesús Sánchez over 0.5 bases (-165)
- Edge: 6.6%
- Probability: 68.9%
- Game: D-Backs vs. Rockies (8:40PM ET)
The data highlights value on Jesús Sánchez over 0.5 bases, with simulations showing a 68.9% probability and a 6.6% edge at -165.
Jesús Sánchez to get a hit (-165)
- Edge: 6.6%
- Probability: 68.9%
- Game: D-Backs vs. Rockies (8:40PM ET)
Our model finds value on Jesús Sánchez to get a hit, with a 68.9% probability and an edge of 6.6% at -165 odds.
Jeffrey Springs over 4.5 hits allowed (-148)
- Edge: 8.3%
- Probability: 68.0%
- Game: Angels vs. Athletics (9:40PM ET)
Simulations indicate value on Jeffrey Springs over 4.5 hits allowed for Athletics, showing an edge of 8.3% at -148 odds.
Nolan McLean under 2.5 walks allowed (-175)
- Edge: 3.4%
- Probability: 67.0%
- Game: Mets vs. Rangers (8:05PM ET)
Nolan McLean’s walks allowed prop shows an edge of 3.4% at -175 odds, supported by a 67.0% probability according to our model.
Pavin Smith to get a hit (-180)
- Edge: 2.6%
- Probability: 66.9%
- Game: D-Backs vs. Rockies (8:40PM ET)
Our model highlights value on Pavin Smith to get a hit for D-Backs, with a 66.9% probability and a 2.6% edge at -180 odds.
Ian Seymour under 6.5 strikeouts (-155)
- Edge: 5.7%
- Probability: 66.5%
- Game: Rays vs. Yankees (7:05PM ET)
The data shows value on Ian Seymour under 6.5 strikeouts, supported by a 66.5% probability at -155 odds and an edge of 5.7%.
Ryan Gusto over 1.5 earned runs (-161)
- Edge: 4.2%
- Probability: 65.9%
- Game: Marlins vs. Cubs (7:40PM ET)
A 4.2% edge on the over 6.5 earned runs line makes Ryan Gusto a value play in Marlins vs. Cubs, supported by a 65.9% probability at -161 odds.
Merrill Kelly over 3.5 strikeouts (-136)
- Edge: 6.2%
- Probability: 63.8%
- Game: D-Backs vs. Rockies (8:40PM ET)
Simulations show value on Merrill Kelly over 3.5 strikeouts here, with a 63.8% probability and 6.2% edge at -136 odds.
MLB player prop summary: Wednesday, September 23, 2026
A quick summary of today’s top props by probability according to our model as of 7:56PM ET:
| Matchup | Prop | Odds | Edge | Prob. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rays vs. Yankees | Gerrit Cole o0.5 walks allowed | -229 @ DraftKings | 8.2% | 77.8% |
| Astros vs. Mariners | George Kirby u1.5 walks allowed | -174 @ DraftKings | 9.1% | 72.6% |
| D-Backs vs. Rockies | Jesús Sánchez o0.5 bases | -165 @ BetMGM | 6.6% | 68.9% |
| D-Backs vs. Rockies | Jesús Sánchez to get a hit | -165 @ BetMGM | 6.6% | 68.9% |
| Angels vs. Athletics | Jeffrey Springs o4.5 hits allowed | -148 @ DraftKings | 8.3% | 68.0% |
| Mets vs. Rangers | Nolan McLean u2.5 walks allowed | -175 @ DraftKings | 3.4% | 67.0% |
| D-Backs vs. Rockies | Pavin Smith to get a hit | -180 @ BetRivers | 2.6% | 66.9% |
| Rays vs. Yankees | Ian Seymour u6.5 strikeouts | -155 @ BetMGM | 5.7% | 66.5% |
| Marlins vs. Cubs | Ryan Gusto o1.5 earned runs | -161 @ DraftKings | 4.2% | 65.9% |
| D-Backs vs. Rockies | Merrill Kelly o3.5 strikeouts | -136 @ FanDuel | 6.2% | 63.8% |
Conclusion
For September 23, 2026, our MLB prop bets feature players such as Gerrit Cole, George Kirby and Jesús Sánchez. Each pick is grounded in real-time data and advanced simulations to help you bet with clarity and purpose.
Built using automation and human oversight, this article draws on the latest data to deliver accurate, timely insights. If using this article for betting, Dimers promotes responsible gambling.


