Louisiana vs. prediction markets: What happens next?

profile-img
Written by Damien Souness
Reviewed by Nick Slade

The CFTC is challenging Louisiana's sweeping restrictions, with federal and state court hearings approaching.

Louisiana State Capitol.
The Louisiana State Capitol in Baton Rouge amid legal challenges to prediction markets.

Louisiana has ordered some of the biggest names in prediction markets to stop offering sports, election, and awards contracts in the state, setting up another confrontation over who gets to regulate the rapidly growing industry.

The November 12 ruling targets companies associated with Kalshi, Polymarket, Robinhood, Crypto.com, Coinbase, and several other platforms. It requires operators to block access to prohibited contracts for people in Louisiana, even if those contracts are offered through federally regulated exchanges.

But the restrictions may not be the final word.

Just one day after the order was issued, the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) sued Louisiana, arguing that the state was interfering with markets subject to federal oversight.

With a temporary ban already in effect, a federal hearing scheduled for November 23, and further proceedings concerning the state's request for a longer-lasting injunction, the coming weeks could determine whether Louisiana's restrictions remain in place or face a successful legal challenge.

For prediction market users, the immediate issue is access. For the industry, what's at stake is much larger: whether individual states can restrict products offered by federally regulated exchanges.

What exactly did Louisiana ban?

Louisiana Attorney General Liz Murrill secured an emergency temporary restraining order from Judge Jeffrey Johnson of the 21st Judicial District Court in Tangipahoa Parish on November 12.

The order covers event contracts tied to sports, elections, and awards, along with other contracts falling within its definition of prohibited wagering.

It reaches beyond the exchanges themselves, restricting activities including offering, brokering, clearing, settling, and making markets in covered contracts without the required Louisiana authorization.

Companies must also geofence Louisiana to prevent people located in the state from accessing prohibited offerings.

The restrictions affect entities associated with major prediction market platforms, including Kalshi, Polymarket US, Robinhood, Crypto.com, Coinbase, Underdog, Novig, and others.

That breadth makes Louisiana's action particularly significant. Rather than targeting a single operator or only sports contracts, the state has sought restrictions across much of the prediction market industry.

The ruling was issued without first hearing arguments from the defendants. It is a temporary measure, not a final determination of whether the contracts are lawful.

Why is Louisiana challenging prediction markets?

Louisiana argues that the event contracts covered by its lawsuit amount to gambling and cannot be offered without complying with state licensing requirements.

Murrill has rejected the argument that describing the products as federally regulated derivatives exempts them from Louisiana gambling laws.

Prediction market operators take a different view.

Companies such as Kalshi argue that contracts traded on CFTC-regulated exchanges fall under federal derivatives law, rather than the separate gambling frameworks used to regulate traditional sportsbooks.

That disagreement has fueled legal disputes across the country, particularly as sports-related contracts have become an increasingly important part of prediction market activity.

Louisiana's action goes further by including election and awards contracts, raising questions about how broadly states can restrict event-based trading.

What happens next? Three key dates

The immediate future of Louisiana's restrictions depends on several legal developments.

November 22: The temporary order is due to expire

Louisiana's restraining order lasts 10 days from its November 12 issuance.

Under its original terms, it is scheduled to expire on November 22 unless extended or replaced by another court order.

The court can extend it for good cause, generally in increments of up to 10 days. The defendants can also agree to a longer period.

That means November 22 is not necessarily when prediction markets will return to Louisiana.

November 23: Kalshi's federal court hearing

Kalshi has separately challenged Louisiana's ability to enforce its gambling laws against the exchange.

A hearing on Kalshi's request for a preliminary injunction is scheduled for November 23 in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Louisiana.

Kalshi, which withdrew its separate request for an immediate temporary restraining order at a November 13 status conference while continuing to pursue preliminary injunctive relief, is seeking protection from state enforcement on the grounds that federal law governs its exchange.

A favorable ruling could strengthen its position against Louisiana's restrictions, although the precise effect would depend on the court's decision.

November 30: The scheduled preliminary injunction hearing

The original state court order scheduled a hearing on Louisiana's request for a preliminary injunction for November 30.

Unlike the initial temporary restraining order, a preliminary injunction could keep restrictions in place while the underlying lawsuit proceeds.

However, subsequent reporting indicates that Louisiana's state court case has been removed to federal court, where further motions have been filed.

That development creates uncertainty over whether the November 30 hearing will proceed as originally scheduled or whether the federal court will first resolve questions about jurisdiction and the existing order.

These proceedings could produce different outcomes, and the dates themselves do not guarantee that access will be restored or restrictions made permanent.

Why has the CFTC sued Louisiana?

The federal regulator entered the dispute directly on November 13, filing a lawsuit challenging Louisiana's restrictions on CFTC-regulated exchanges and related businesses.

In its official announcement, the CFTC accused Louisiana of interfering with federally regulated markets and said it was defending the authority granted to it under the Commodity Exchange Act.

The agency argues that Congress gave it exclusive jurisdiction over derivatives markets governed by federal law.

Its federal complaint seeks to prevent Louisiana from enforcing restrictions that the CFTC believes intrude on that authority.

The CFTC says Louisiana is the 12th state it has sued in defense of its jurisdiction over prediction markets.

The federal regulator's intervention changes the dispute from a fight between individual companies and state authorities into a confrontation between state and federal regulators.

But filing the lawsuit does not automatically overturn Louisiana's court order. The federal courts must still decide what relief, if any, is appropriate.

The geofencing problem makes the dispute even more complicated

Louisiana's order creates a particularly difficult situation because it requires affected operators to block access to prohibited contracts from within the state.

That requirement comes shortly after the CFTC told federally regulated exchanges to address geographic restrictions that could violate the principle of impartial access.

Under the CFTC's November guidance, exchanges were given 30 days to stop certain forms of domestic geofencing or explain why doing so was not feasible.

The resulting tension is obvious.

Louisiana is directing operators to restrict access, while the federal regulator is challenging the use of state-based restrictions on markets under its supervision.

The CFTC's guidance allows exchanges to explain circumstances that prevent compliance, but it remains unclear how the agency will ultimately treat conflicting state court orders.

For operators facing both state litigation and federal regulatory obligations, the question is no longer simply whether to offer sports contracts.

It's how to comply with competing legal demands while the courts determine which authority takes precedence.

What does this ruling mean for Kalshi and Polymarket users in Louisiana?

For customers physically located in Louisiana, the court order requires affected operators to restrict access to covered event contracts while the order remains in force.

That includes sports contracts, but the restrictions also extend to elections and awards.

However, the order should not be interpreted as a permanent nationwide ban or a final ruling that all prediction markets are illegal.

It does not necessarily mean that all products or services offered by the named companies are prohibited.

The practical impact on existing positions, account balances, and withdrawals may differ by platform. Customers should check official operator notices rather than assume that the court order automatically closes accounts or cancels existing contracts.

Anyone considering using a prediction market should verify the current availability and legal restrictions applicable to their location.

Could Louisiana's case affect prediction markets nationwide?

Potentially, although the immediate orders and lawsuits concern Louisiana.

The underlying question is already being contested in multiple jurisdictions: can states apply their gambling laws to event contracts offered through federally regulated exchanges?

A ruling supporting Louisiana could encourage other states to pursue similarly broad restrictions.

A ruling supporting Kalshi or the CFTC could strengthen the argument that federally regulated exchanges should not face separate state gambling requirements for the same contracts.

Neither outcome would necessarily settle the issue nationwide. Different courts could reach different conclusions, and further appeals could follow.

The inclusion of election and awards contracts also makes Louisiana's case important beyond the sports betting debate.

It raises the possibility that state restrictions could reach a much wider range of prediction market products than those directly competing with sportsbooks.

What should prediction market users watch now?

The next significant developments are whether Louisiana's temporary order is extended, what happens at Kalshi's November 23 federal hearing, and how the courts handle the state's request for longer-lasting restrictions.

The CFTC's separate lawsuit adds another potential route for challenging the restrictions.

For now, there is no final resolution.

Louisiana believes the affected contracts violate its gambling laws. The operators and federal regulator argue that those state restrictions cannot apply to federally regulated derivatives markets in the same way.

What happens next could help determine not just where Americans can trade prediction market contracts, but also who ultimately gets to decide.

profile-img
To give you the most accurate and helpful information, this article has been reviewed and edited by Nick Slade through our fact-checking process.
profile-img
Written by
Damien Souness
Chief Experience Officer

Damien Souness is Chief Experience Officer at Cipher Sports Technology Group, helping lead sports media brands such as Dimers. He specializes in creating trustworthy and data-driven content for sports fans, with experience working for globally recognized sports and media organizations.

Advertiser disclosure

Related Articles

More Articles
Dimers Sports
The big spin: Can blockchain make online slots more transparent?
Read Article
Dimers Sports
DraftKings Football Moonshot explained: How it works and the risks
Read Article
Dimers Sports
Prediction markets' new dilemma: Follow the CFTC or the courts?
Read Article