"Maye-day" in New England: Patriots' playoff chances take massive hit

profile-img
Written by Dave Garofolo
Reviewed by Nick Slade

The New England Patriots' playoff chances took a huge hit after Drake Maye's ankle injury.

New England Patriots, Drake Maye injury, NFL predictions, Super Bowl probabilities.
QB Drake Maye sustained what the team fears to be a season-ending ankle injury in Week 10.

It's not over til it's over, but in the wake of Patriots QB Drake Maye's ankle injury, New England's playoff chances have been cut nearly in half.

Before Maye's ankle injury, Dimers' NFL predictions model had New England competing for the playoffs via a Wild Card spot, and now they're floating on the wrong side of the postseason bubble.

Maye went down on the final play of the opening drive in Sunday's 35-10 loss to the Detroit Lions in Munich, after a sack by Aidan Hutchinson, and he did not return.

Sidelined indefinitely, the team fears the injury is a fractured ankle and could be season-ending, doubly so for the now 5-5 Patriots.

Patriots: From Super Bowl contender to outside the playoffs

Though we highlighted New England as a prime regression candidate in the preseason, as recently as Week 6, New England sat inside the top 10 of Dimers' Super Bowl predictions. The model had them at a 6.8% title chance, 11.5% to win the AFC and 36.0% to take the division.

Those numbers held steady through Week 8, then started to slip. Following Maye's injury, the Week 9 to Week 10 drop is where things plummeted:

Market

After Week 8

After Week 9

After Week 10

Super Bowl

6.1%

4.5%

0.6%

AFC title

8.7%

5.1%

1.4%

AFC East

22.8%

8.1%

0.8%

In one week, their Super Bowl probability fell by almost 90%. Division odds are now equally close to zero, with the Bills at 8-1 and three and a half games clear.

Their AFC title chance is the highest, because mathematically, they can still get in via Wild Card, despite the division chances being close to nil.

Why the model moved so far against the Pats

This drop is indicative of how much of New England's offense ran through Maye. Entering Week 10, he ranked top five in the league in QBR (74.2) and QB rushing yards (219), with 18 touchdown passes and 8.4 yards per attempt.

NFL Futures AFC East.Dimers' AFC East predictions after Week 10.

Backup QB Tommy DeVito now takes over. He went 12 of 24 for 81 yards and an interception in relief, and the offense managed 82 yards over 10 drives after Maye left. In eight career starts with the Giants, DeVito is 3-5 with a 26.4 QBR.

The schedule doesn't help much. After the bye come the Chargers, who finally managed a win against a team in a similar boat, the Ravens, then the Bills, Vikings and Chiefs in a four-week stretch. That's three Super Bowl contenders on deck.

Week 12 lookahead: Patriots at Chargers

The Patriots are on bye in Week 11, which at least gives them the advantage of nearly two full weeks of prep with DeVito under center.

Their first test comes in Chargers vs. Patriots, against a 1-8 Los Angeles team at SoFi Stadium on Sunday, November 29. The market has New England as a 5.5-point road underdog, and our model currently has them covering the spread:

  • Spread: Patriots +5.5 (-115), Chargers -5.5 (-115)
  • Moneyline: Patriots +210, Chargers -230
  • Total: 40.5 (-115/-115)

The Dimers model gives the Patriots a 38.7% chance to win and projects a 21-18 Chargers victory. At +210, the moneyline implies about 32.3%.

The total is where it looks to take the biggest hit. Based on our projected final score, 39 combined points sits under the adjusted total of 40.5, which is down from the opening 46 line.

What's next for New England

At 5-5 with a 35.8% playoff chance, New England is still in the wild-card picture. Their chances to make the playoffs were nearly cut in half, but a 35.8% chance isn't meaningless.

The competition behind the Pats with the Raiders, Texans and Ravens isn't very good, so all they need is to hang around and get some help from a Browns collapse, as they currently occupy the 7-seed.

Responsible Gambling

Please gamble responsibly. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, call 1-800-MY-RESET.

profile-img
To give you the most accurate and helpful information, this article has been reviewed and edited by Nick Slade through our fact-checking process.
profile-img
Written by
Dave Garofolo
Content Producer

Dave Garofolo uses sophisticated AI-driven analytics to make predictions and evaluate player performances in the NBA, MLB, NFL, NHL, NCAAM, and PGA TOUR tournaments, crafting insightful game and prop previews.

Advertiser disclosure

Related Articles

More Articles
Dimers Sports
NFL Week 11 betting guide: Model backed picks, top player props and sharp Pick 'Ems
Read Article
Dimers Sports
NFL Week 10 betting recap: Where the Dimers model dominated and why it pays to follow
Read Article
Dimers Sports
Chargers vs. Ravens prediction favors Baltimore to win MNF Week 10 [2026]
Read Article