Pirates vs. Cardinals Prediction, Picks and Odds

Our detailed prediction and analysis for the Pirates vs. Cardinals MLB game on May 19, 2026 is featured below. Drawing from 10,000 game simulations, we provide expert picks, betting odds, and insights.
FINAL
MLB
Add this game to My Favorites
FINAL
Add this game to My Favorites
MLB sport icon
MLB
Pirates
Mitch Keller 4-2, 3.59 ERA
6
9
May 19, 7:45 PM ET Busch Stadium
Cardinals
Matthew Liberatore 2-2, 4.40 ERA
May 19, 7:45 PM ET Busch Stadium
2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 RHE
Pirates
0 0 0 4 0 0 0 2 0 6 12 0
Cardinals
0 2 1 0 2 0 1 0 3 9 9 2
Live Probabilities
Win %
  • Pirates
    0%
  • Cardinals
    100%
Win Probability
Baseball infield diamond diagram
Last At Bat
Outs
Ivan Herrera homers to center field. JJ Wetherholt scores. Victor Scott scores.
Quick Box Score
Pirates Hitting
No.PlayerPosABRHRBIHRBBSOAVGOPS
1 N. Gonzales 3B5210011.2000.533
2 K. Griffin SS4110002.2500.650
3 B. Reynolds LF4112001.2500.900
4 M. Ozuna DH3000022.0000.400
5 O. Cruz CF4021012.5001.100
6 S. Horwitz 1B10110001.0002.000
7 B. Lowe 2B5120002.4000.800
8 J. Mangum RF1000001.0000.000
9 E. Rodríguez C2000000.0000.000
Cardinals Hitting
No.PlayerPosABRHRBIHRBBSOAVGOPS
1 J. Wetherholt 2B4222111.5001.850
2 I. Herrera DH5113102.2001.000
3 A. Burleson 1B3321100.6672.417
4 J. Walker RF4010000.2500.500
5 N. Gorman 3B3112110.3331.833
6 N. Church LF4010001.2500.500
7 T. Saggese SS1000011.0000.500
8 P. Pagés C3110011.3330.833
9 V. Scott CF3100001.0000.000

Pirates vs. Cardinals: Detailed Breakdown

Matchup Overview

  • Teams: Pirates vs. Cardinals
  • Date: Tuesday, May 19, 2026
  • Time: 7:45 PM ET
  • Venue: Busch Stadium

Current Betting Odds

  • Spread: Cardinals favored at -1.5
  • Total (Over/Under): 7.5
  • Moneyline Odds: Pirates +111, Cardinals -108

Dimers' Win Probabilities

  • Pirates: 48%
  • Cardinals: 52%

Dimers' predictive model, renowned for its accuracy, assesses each team's chances by simulating the outcome of the game 10,000 times. This method provides a precise and unbiased view.

Our Prediction: Who Wins?

After extensive simulations, our model gives the Pirates a win probability of 48%, while the Cardinals have a win probability of 52%. Discover the best spread, over/under, and moneyline odds for the game on this page.

Summary

According to our analysis, the Cardinals are more likely to beat the Pirates in the MLB game at Busch Stadium on Tuesday. Discover the best spread, over/under and moneyline odds, picks and probabilities for the game on this page.

Our Pirates vs. Cardinals predictions, based on sophisticated simulations and current data, guide you in making informed decisions. Remember to bet responsibly and within your financial limits.

For additional resources and advice on responsible gambling, please call 1-800-GAMBLER.

When you click or tap on a link on Dimers that goes to a third-party website that we have a commercial relationship with (such as a sportsbook), we may receive a referral fee.

For further insights, explore our expert MLB predictions and the best MLB bets today, while our in-depth analysis includes MLB props, MLB futures, MLB odds, and the latest MLB news.