Islanders vs. Maple Leafs: NHL Prediction & Analysis

Our detailed prediction and analysis for the Islanders vs. Maple Leafs NHL game on Wednesday, September 30, 2026 is featured below. Drawing from 10,000 game simulations, we provide expert picks, betting odds, and insights.
FINAL
NHL
FINAL
NHL sport icon
NHL
Islanders
1
2
Scotiabank Arena
Maple Leafs
Scotiabank Arena
TEAM123T
Islanders
0 0 1 1
Maple Leafs
2 0 0 2
Live Probabilities
Win %
  • Islanders
    0%
  • Maple Leafs
    100%
Win Probability
TEAM123T
Islanders
0 0 1 1
Maple Leafs
2 0 0 2
P3 19:26 Shot missed by Matthew Schaefer
P3 18:57 Matthew Schaefer shot blocked by Auston Matthews
P3 18:49 Simon Holmstrom shot blocked by Jake McCabe
P3 18:01 Shot missed by Tony DeAngelo
P3 16:30 Shot missed by Simon Holmstrom
P3 15:42 Gavin McKenna shot blocked by Matias Maccelli
P3 15:22 Power play - Shot on goal by Gavin McKenna saved by Ilya Sorokin
P3 14:09 Shorthanded - Goal scored by Emil Heineman
P3 13:45 Power play - Shot on goal by Darren Raddysh saved by Ilya Sorokin
P3 12:37 Power play - Shot missed by Bo Horvat
P3 12:23 Power play - Shot missed by Victor Eklund
P3 07:42 Power play - Matthew Schaefer shot blocked by Brandon Duhaime
P3 07:34 Power play - Matthew Schaefer shot blocked by Colton Sissons
P3 06:38 Anthony Duclair shot blocked by Chris Tanev
P3 06:07 Adam Pelech shot blocked by Chris Tanev
P3 05:11 Logan Stanley shot blocked by Brandon Duhaime
P3 03:15 Jake McCabe shot blocked by Ryan Pulock
P3 03:05 Shot on goal by Brandon Duhaime saved by Ilya Sorokin
P3 02:11 William Nylander shot blocked by Anthony Duclair
P3 02:08 Darren Raddysh shot blocked by Anthony Duclair
Play by Play
  1. P3 20:00
    End of 3rd Period.
  2. P3 19:26
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Matthew Schaefer
  3. P3 18:57
    SHOT
    Matthew Schaefer shot blocked by Auston Matthews
  4. P3 18:49
    SHOT
    Simon Holmstrom shot blocked by Jake McCabe
  5. P3 18:33
    Bo Horvat won faceoff against Colton Sissons in offensive zone
  6. P3 18:33
    Stoppage - Icing
  7. P3 18:01
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Tony DeAngelo
  8. P3 17:14
    Jean-Gabriel Pageau won faceoff against Teddy Blueger in offensive zone
  9. P3 16:30
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Simon Holmstrom
  10. P3 16:00
    Bo Horvat won faceoff against Auston Matthews in offensive zone
  11. P3 15:54
    Auston Matthews won faceoff against Bo Horvat in neutral zone
  12. P3 15:54
    Stoppage - Offside - TV timeout
  13. P3 15:42
    SHOT
    Gavin McKenna shot blocked by Matias Maccelli
  14. P3 15:22
    SHOT
    Power play - Shot on goal by Gavin McKenna saved by Ilya Sorokin
  15. P3 14:09
    Shorthanded - Jean-Gabriel Pageau won faceoff against Nick Paul in neutral zone
  16. P3 14:09
    GOAL
    Shorthanded - Goal scored by Emil Heineman
    1-2
  17. P3 13:45
    SHOT
    Power play - Shot on goal by Darren Raddysh saved by Ilya Sorokin
  18. P3 13:32
    Power play - John Tavares won faceoff against Jean-Gabriel Pageau in offensive zone
  19. P3 12:37
    SHOT
    Power play - Shot missed by Bo Horvat
  20. P3 12:26
    Stoppage - Puck in Netting
  21. P3 12:23
    SHOT
    Power play - Shot missed by Victor Eklund
  22. P3 11:10
    Power play - Matias Maccelli credited with hit on Chris Tanev in offensive zone
  23. P3 11:08
    Shorthanded - Oliver Ekman-Larsson credited with hit on Kyle Palmieri in defensive zone
  24. P3 10:50
    Power play - Bo Horvat won faceoff against Colton Sissons in offensive zone
  25. P3 09:32
    John Tavares won faceoff against Jean-Gabriel Pageau in offensive zone
  26. P3 09:32
    Stoppage - Icing
  27. P3 09:04
    Jean-Gabriel Pageau won faceoff against Auston Matthews in offensive zone
  28. P3 07:42
    SHOT
    Power play - Matthew Schaefer shot blocked by Brandon Duhaime
  29. P3 07:34
    SHOT
    Power play - Matthew Schaefer shot blocked by Colton Sissons
  30. P3 06:59
    Shorthanded - Colton Sissons won faceoff against Brayden Schenn in defensive zone
  31. P3 06:59
    Stoppage - TV timeout
  32. P3 06:55
    Casey Cizikas won faceoff against Auston Matthews in defensive zone
  33. P3 06:38
    SHOT
    Anthony Duclair shot blocked by Chris Tanev
  34. P3 06:20
    Giveaway by Gavin McKenna in defensive zone
  35. P3 06:07
    SHOT
    Adam Pelech shot blocked by Chris Tanev
  36. P3 05:11
    SHOT
    Logan Stanley shot blocked by Brandon Duhaime
  37. P3 04:28
    Giveaway by Darren Raddysh in defensive zone
  38. P3 04:25
    Bo Groulx won faceoff against Victor Eklund in neutral zone
  39. P3 04:17
    Stoppage - Puck in Benches
  40. P3 03:40
    Islanders won faceoff against Maple Leafs in neutral zone
  41. P3 03:15
    SHOT
    Jake McCabe shot blocked by Ryan Pulock
  42. P3 03:07
    Jack Roslovic won faceoff against Casey Cizikas in offensive zone
  43. P3 03:07
    Stoppage - Goalie Stopped (after SOG)
  44. P3 03:05
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Brandon Duhaime saved by Ilya Sorokin
  45. P3 02:11
    SHOT
    William Nylander shot blocked by Anthony Duclair
  46. P3 02:08
    SHOT
    Darren Raddysh shot blocked by Anthony Duclair
  47. P3 00:47
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Kirill Marchenko saved by Ilya Sorokin
  48. P3 00:07
    Stoppage - Puck in Benches
  49. P3 00:00
    Shorthanded - Casey Cizikas won faceoff against Auston Matthews in neutral zone
  50. P2 20:00
    End of 2nd Period.
  51. P2 19:50
    Islanders won faceoff against Maple Leafs in neutral zone
  52. P2 19:30
    Islanders won faceoff against Maple Leafs in neutral zone
  53. P2 19:20
    SHOT
    Power play - Shot missed by William Nylander
  54. P2 18:31
    SHOT
    Power play - Darren Raddysh shot blocked by Ryan Pulock
  55. P2 18:14
    Power play - John Tavares won faceoff against Jean-Gabriel Pageau in offensive zone
  56. P2 18:12
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by John Tavares saved by Ilya Sorokin
  57. P2 17:35
    Delayed penalty (against the Islanders)
  58. P2 17:27
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Brandon Duhaime saved by Ilya Sorokin
  59. P2 16:14
    Jack Roslovic won faceoff against Jean-Gabriel Pageau in offensive zone
  60. P2 16:12
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Auston Matthews
  61. P2 16:11
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Oliver Ekman-Larsson saved by Ilya Sorokin
  62. P2 14:53
    Islanders won faceoff against Bo Groulx in neutral zone
  63. P2 14:53
    Stoppage - TV timeout
  64. P2 14:22
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Colton Sissons
  65. P2 14:04
    SHOT
    Jake McCabe shot blocked by Calum Ritchie
  66. P2 13:55
    Calum Ritchie won faceoff against Nick Paul in defensive zone
  67. P2 13:22
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Kirill Marchenko saved by Ilya Sorokin
  68. P2 12:38
    SHOT
    Victor Eklund shot blocked by William Nylander
  69. P2 12:24
    SHOT
    Matthew Schaefer shot blocked by Morgan Rielly
  70. P2 12:04
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Logan Stanley saved by Anthony Stolarz
  71. P2 11:34
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Easton Cowan
  72. P2 11:09
    Giveaway by Adam Pelech in defensive zone
  73. P2 10:37
    SHOT
    Adam Pelech shot blocked by teammate
  74. P2 10:06
    SHOT
    Power play - Bo Horvat shot blocked by Jake McCabe
  75. P2 10:03
    SHOT
    Power play - Brayden Schenn shot blocked by Teddy Blueger
  76. P2 09:48
    Power play - Giveaway by Bo Horvat in offensive zone
  77. P2 09:31
    SHOT
    Power play - Kyle Palmieri shot blocked by Jake McCabe
  78. P2 08:35
    Power play - Bo Horvat won faceoff against Colton Sissons in offensive zone
  79. P2 08:29
    Colton Sissons won faceoff against Calum Ritchie in offensive zone
  80. P2 08:27
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Jake McCabe saved by Ilya Sorokin
  81. P2 08:25
    Nick Paul won faceoff against Bo Horvat in offensive zone
  82. P2 08:18
    Bo Horvat won faceoff against Colton Sissons in defensive zone
  83. P2 08:14
    Giveaway by Ilya Sorokin in defensive zone
  84. P2 08:05
    Colton Sissons won faceoff against Bo Horvat in defensive zone
  85. P2 08:05
    Stoppage - Goalie Stopped (after SOG)
  86. P2 07:21
    SHOT
    Adam Pelech shot blocked by Jack Roslovic
  87. P2 06:39
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Alexander Romanov saved by Anthony Stolarz
  88. P2 06:37
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Anthony Duclair saved by Anthony Stolarz
  89. P2 06:26
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Ondrej Palat saved by Anthony Stolarz
  90. P2 05:04
    SHOT
    Power play - Bo Horvat shot blocked by Brandon Duhaime
  91. P2 03:56
    Power play - Giveaway by Bo Horvat in offensive zone
  92. P2 03:41
    Power play - Brayden Schenn won faceoff against Colton Sissons in offensive zone
  93. P2 03:41
    Penalty to John Tavares 2 minutes for Slashing (Drawn by Casey Cizikas)
  94. P2 03:35
    Delayed penalty (against the Maple Leafs)
  95. P2 01:59
    Teddy Blueger won faceoff against Calum Ritchie in offensive zone
  96. P2 01:59
    Stoppage - Icing
  97. P2 00:53
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Bo Horvat saved by Anthony Stolarz
  98. P2 00:00
    Jean-Gabriel Pageau won faceoff against Auston Matthews in neutral zone
  99. P1 20:00
    End of 1st Period.
  100. P1 19:54
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Matthew Schaefer saved by Anthony Stolarz
  101. P1 19:00
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Colton Sissons
  102. P1 18:43
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Kyle Palmieri
  103. P1 18:34
    Bo Horvat won faceoff against Colton Sissons in neutral zone
  104. P1 18:34
    Stoppage - Hand Pass
  105. P1 18:09
    SHOT
    Oliver Ekman-Larsson shot blocked by teammate
  106. P1 17:55
    SHOT
    Brandon Duhaime shot blocked by Matthew Schaefer
  107. P1 17:41
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Morgan Rielly
  108. P1 16:49
    SHOT
    Power play - Shot missed by Jack Roslovic
  109. P1 16:41
    Islanders won faceoff against Maple Leafs in neutral zone
  110. P1 16:41
    Stoppage - Goalie Stopped (after SOG)
  111. P1 15:25
    Shorthanded - Jean-Gabriel Pageau won faceoff against John Tavares in defensive zone
  112. P1 15:25
    Stoppage - TV timeout
  113. P1 14:00
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Anthony Duclair saved by Anthony Stolarz
  114. P1 13:54
    Casey Cizikas won faceoff against John Tavares in defensive zone
  115. P1 13:43
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Jack Roslovic saved by Ilya Sorokin
  116. P1 13:09
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Simon Holmstrom
  117. P1 12:37
    Colton Sissons won faceoff against Bo Horvat in neutral zone
  118. P1 12:37
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Logan Stanley
  119. P1 12:34
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Kyle Palmieri saved by Anthony Stolarz
  120. P1 12:17
    Islanders won faceoff against Maple Leafs in neutral zone
  121. P1 12:17
    Stoppage - Puck in Netting
  122. P1 11:55
    GOAL
    Power play - Goal scored by Easton Cowan assisted by Jack Roslovic
    0-2
  123. P1 11:53
    SHOT
    Power play - Shot on goal by Jack Roslovic saved by Ilya Sorokin
  124. P1 11:04
    SHOT
    Power play - William Nylander shot blocked by Logan Stanley
  125. P1 10:01
    Power play - John Tavares won faceoff against Jean-Gabriel Pageau in offensive zone
  126. P1 10:01
    Penalty to Victor Eklund 2 minutes for Cross Checking (Drawn by John Tavares)
  127. P1 09:47
    Delayed penalty (against the Islanders)
  128. P1 09:22
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Bo Horvat saved by Anthony Stolarz
  129. P1 09:06
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Bo Horvat saved by Anthony Stolarz
  130. P1 08:30
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Easton Cowan saved by Ilya Sorokin
  131. P1 07:47
    Giveaway by Matthew Schaefer in neutral zone
  132. P1 07:14
    Calum Ritchie won faceoff against Auston Matthews in neutral zone
  133. P1 07:04
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Nick Paul saved by Ilya Sorokin
  134. P1 06:54
    Colton Sissons won faceoff against Emil Heineman in neutral zone
  135. P1 06:54
    Stoppage - Offside - TV timeout
  136. P1 06:24
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Adam Pelech
  137. P1 05:04
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Brayden Schenn saved by Anthony Stolarz
  138. P1 04:34
    Islanders won faceoff against Maple Leafs in neutral zone
  139. P1 03:45
    Auston Matthews won faceoff against Jean-Gabriel Pageau in neutral zone
  140. P1 02:22
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Ondrej Palat
  141. P1 02:21
    SHOT
    Tony DeAngelo shot blocked by teammate
  142. P1 02:04
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Matthew Schaefer saved by Anthony Stolarz
  143. P1 01:43
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Adam Pelech
  144. P1 00:35
    Auston Matthews won faceoff against Victor Eklund in defensive zone
  145. P1 00:35
    Stoppage - Goalie Stopped (after SOG)
  146. P1 00:27
    SHOT
    Shot on goal by Kyle Palmieri saved by Anthony Stolarz
  147. P1 00:24
    SHOT
    Shot missed by Kyle Palmieri
  148. P1 00:00
    Nick Paul won faceoff against Bo Horvat in neutral zone
  149. P1 00:00
    Game Setup.
Stats
Islanders
STATS
Maple Leafs
27Shots on Goal26
40% Faceoff Win % 60%
4/0 PP Opportunities/PP Goals 4/1
8Penalty Infraction Mins8
24Hits19
11 Shots Blocked 21
12Giveaways15
IslandersNYI
Maple LeafsTOR
27Shots on Goal26
40% Faceoff Win % 60%
4/0 PP Opportunities/PP Goals 4/1
8Penalty Infraction Mins8
24Hits19
11 Shots Blocked 21
12Giveaways15

Islanders vs. Maple Leafs: Detailed Breakdown

Matchup overview: NHL Wednesday

  • Teams: NY Islanders Islanders vs. Toronto Maple Leafs
  • Date: Wednesday, September 30, 2026
  • Time: 7:30PM ET
  • Venue: Scotiabank Arena

Current betting odds

  • Puck line: Islanders (+1.5, -217), Maple Leafs (-1.5, +190)
  • Moneyline: Islanders +125, Maple Leafs -135
  • Total (Over/Under): 6 goals (-110/-110)

Dimers’ win probabilities

  • Islanders: 45.4%
  • Maple Leafs: 54.6%

Dimers' predictive NHL model, renowned for its accuracy, assesses each team's chances by simulating the outcome of the game 10,000 times. This method provides a precise and unbiased view.

Our Prediction: Who Wins?

After extensive simulations, our model gives the Islanders a win probability of 45.4%, while the Maple Leafs have a win probability of 54.6%.

Summary

According to our analysis, the Maple Leafs are more likely to beat the Islanders in the NHL game at Scotiabank Arena on Wednesday. Discover the best puck line, over/under and moneyline odds, picks and probabilities for the game on this page.

Our Islanders vs. Maple Leafs predictions, based on sophisticated simulations and current data, guide you in making informed decisions. Remember to bet responsibly and within your financial limits.

For additional resources and advice on responsible gambling, please call 1-800-GAMBLER.

When you click or tap on a link on Dimers that goes to a third-party website that we have a commercial relationship with (such as a sportsbook), we may receive a referral fee.

For further insights, explore our expert NHL predictions and the best NHL bets today, while our in-depth analysis includes NHL props, NHL futures, NHL odds, and the latest NHL news.