MLB Prop Bets Today: Tuesday, May 21, 2024

MLB Prop Bets Today: Tuesday, May 21, 2024

MLB prop betting is back for Tuesday, May 21, 2024, with our prop plays chosen through innovative simulations and machine learning.

These picks aim to refine your betting strategy for a riveting night of MLB action, getting you started with prop plays on Jeff McNeil, Andrew Abbott and Joe Musgrove.

The next three +EV opportunities for the day are listed below, with Dimers Pro users today securing access to 221 MLB props, including our prop of the day.

That prop bet is on a player in the White Sox vs. Blue Jays game to go over his walks allowed line, with our model finding an edge of 28.3% on the best available odds.

Subscribe to unlock this and more data-driven and props and best bets for less than $1 a day with Dimers Pro.

Best MLB Prop Picks - Tuesday

Tuesday's MLB prop betting action gets started in the Mets vs. Guardians game at 6:10PM ET.

Note: Clicking links to our partners may earn us a referral fee.

Jeff McNeil To Get a Hit (-190)

Our model has found the next MLB prop bet you should make on Tuesday, focusing on the Mets vs. Guardians game, with Jeff McNeil the player we are targetting. We recommend placing a bet on Jeff McNeil To Get a Hit for NY Mets today, with an edge 5.6% availble on the -190 odds.


MORE: MLB Prop Bets

Andrew Abbott Under 2.5 Earned Runs (+100)

Our model has found another +EV prop bet for Tuesday's MLB, with Andrew Abbott in our sights in the Padres - Reds game. We recommend placing a bet on Andrew Abbott Under 2.5 Earned Runs, with an edge of 5.0% available on the +100 odds currently available.


MORE: MLB Best Bets

Joe Musgrove Over 4.5 Strikeouts (-110)

According to our model, the next player prop bet for Tuesday's MLB features Joe Musgrove in the Padres vs. Reds clash. The recommended play here is on Joe Musgrove Over 4.5 Strikeouts, with DimersBOT detecting an edge of 7.7% on the -110 odds available the bookies.


MORE: Trends for NBA Tuesday

MLB Player Prop Picks - Tuesday, May 21, 2024

Our model's next three prop bets to make as of 5:55PM ET:

Matchup Prop Odds Edge
Mets vs. Guardians Jeff McNeil To Get a Hit -190 @ BetMGM 5.6%
Padres vs. Reds Andrew Abbott Under 2.5 Earned Runs +100 @ BetMGM 5.0%
Padres vs. Reds Joe Musgrove Over 4.5 Strikeouts -110 @ BetMGM 7.7%

Remember, by signing up to Dimers Pro, you'll gain access to the rest of the 221 MLB prop bets that our model has found today.

Tuesday's MLB props are highlighted by a play with an edge of 28.3% against the sportsbook odds of +175. Register now to catch all of these props, as well as our full suite of best bets, trends and parlays for Tuesday, May 21, 2024.

JOIN NOW: Access the best sports betting models in the world for less than $1 a day with Dimers Pro.

More About MLB

Today's best bets are part of our MLB player props and MLB best bets series. Get the latest MLB betting news, our analytics-driven MLB predictions and World Series odds for projections on the World Series, American League, National League, and each division all year long.


This article, enhanced by AI and automation, aims to deliver accurate MLB insights quickly, with human oversight ensuring high editorial quality. Our predictions are based on current data to help you make informed decisions. For additional resources and advice on responsible gambling, please call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Jason Bevilacqua
Head of Content and Communities

Jason Bevilacqua has a deep-rooted passion for sports and has been actively involved in sports betting for many years. Specializing in the MLB, NHL, NBA, MLS, and NFL, Jason delivers engaging game previews across these leagues. His expertise is particularly evident in his best bets for MLB, NHL, and college basketball. Additionally, Jason contributes valuable MLB and NFL props, as well as NBA first basket plays. 

Since joining Dimers in 2020 as the Head of Social and Community, Jason has also made significant contributions to the editorial department, offering daily articles that are not only well-researched but also deeply insightful. His strategic approach and collaboration with DimersBOT ensure his betting advice is top-notch.

On the socials
More from Dimers
About Dimers
icon 22,000+
Events covered per year
icon 8,000,000+
Our partners