Columbus vs. NY City Prediction, Picks and Odds

Dimers' prediction and analysis for the Columbus vs. NY City MLS match on September 17, 2025 includes win probabilities and picks for the biggest betting markets. Get Dimers Pro for full access.
Get 6 months of Dimers Pro for just $99.99
FINAL
MLS
Add this game to My Favorites
FINAL
Add this game to My Favorites
MLS sport icon
MLS
Columbus
2
3
Yankee Stadium (New York City)
NY City
Yankee Stadium (New York City)
NY CityNYC
Score Summary
ColumbusCLB
H. Wolf (45')
Soccer ball icon
H. Wolf (73')
Soccer ball icon
J. Fernandez (90')
Soccer ball icon
D. Gazdag (pen.) (40')
Soccer ball icon
W. Abou Ali (60')
Soccer ball icon
Live Probabilities
Win %
  • NY City
    100.0%
  • Draw
    0.0%
  • Columbus
    0.0%
Win Probability
Match Timeline
  1. 90'
    Soccer ball icon
    Goal scored for New York City by J. Fernandez, assisted by A. Ojeda
    2-3
  2. 90'
    Yellow Card
    J. Fernandez (New York City) cautioned
  3. 83'
    Substitution
    Substitution for Columbus Crew: A. Sejdic replaces D. Gazdag
  4. 83'
    Substitution
    Substitution for Columbus Crew: J. Russell-Rowe replaces D. Nagbe
  5. 82'
    Substitution
    Substitution for New York City: J. Shore replaces A. O'Neill
  6. 82'
    Substitution
    Substitution for New York City: S. Garfield Reid replaces N. Mercau
  7. 73'
    Soccer ball icon
    Goal scored for New York City by H. Wolf
    2-2
  8. 71'
    Substitution
    Substitution for Columbus Crew: D. Chambost replaces H. Picard
  9. 67'
    Substitution
    Substitution for New York City: J. Fernandez replaces M. Moralez
  10. 67'
    Substitution
    Substitution for New York City: A. Ojeda replaces A. Martinez
  11. 60'
    Soccer ball icon
    Goal scored for Columbus Crew by W. Abou Ali
    2-1
  12. 46'
    Substitution
    Substitution for Columbus Crew: C. Ruvalcaba replaces S. Moreira
  13. 45'
    Soccer ball icon
    Goal scored for New York City by H. Wolf
    1-1
  14. 40'
    Soccer ball icon
    Goal scored for Columbus Crew by D. Gazdag (pen.)
    1-0

Columbus vs. NY City: Match prediction & analysis

Match overview

  • Teams: Columbus vs. NY City
  • Date: Wednesday, September 17, 2025
  • Time: 7:30 PM ET
  • Venue: Yankee Stadium

Current betting odds

  • Moneyline: Columbus +260, NY City -110, draw +295

Dimers' win & correct score probabilities

  • Columbus: 25.0%
  • NY City: 52.6%
  • Draw: 22.4%

These probabilities are generated using Dimers' MLS data model, which predicts the most likely outcomes for all major betting markets.

Most likely correct score: Columbus 1-1 NY City (10.2%)

Correct score projections are based on expected scoring patterns. A team can have a higher chance of winning overall, even if the single most likely scoreline is a draw or narrow result.

Want Dimers' best bets for this matchup?

The most probable outcome isn't always the wisest wager.

The Dimers betting model calculates probabilities for all match outcomes to identify where it sees the strongest value across the betting markets, ranking every opportunity by model edge.

Join Dimers Pro to unlock complete betting analysis for this matchup across every major market, including:

  • Today's best bets
  • Moneyline probabilities
  • Total goals probabilities
  • Correct score probabilities

Unlock today's best bets for this match with Dimers Pro—cancel anytime.

Who will win Columbus vs. NY City? Prediction & correct score

NY City is the most likely winner of this match with a win probability of 52.6%.

The most likely correct score is Columbus 1-1 NY City.

But the most likely outcomes aren't always the best betting opportunities.

Get Dimers Pro to unlock today's best bets and complete betting analysis for this matchup.

Responsible gambling

Dimers' predictions and betting insights are designed to help inform your betting decisions. If you're betting on Columbus vs. NY City, always gamble responsibly and within your means. For support, you can visit our responsible gambling resources.