Select the sportsbooks and prediction markets you use to unlock more betting opportunities.
Kentucky and the Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) have filed new briefs in their legal dispute over whether the state can regulate sports prediction sites under its gambling laws.
The submissions on October 23 address a recent federal appeals court ruling and the potential impact of the CFTC's rulemaking on event contracts.
The case remains unresolved, but a federal judge has scheduled arguments for December 18, 2026, in Lexington, Kentucky, giving both sides another chance to explain their positions.
The latest briefs came after a court order dated October 5 directed the parties to address the Sixth Circuit's decision in Kalshi v. Schuler and the potential effect of upcoming CFTC rulemaking.
On October 23, Kentucky, the federal government and CFTC, and the Coalition for Fair Markets submitted supplemental memoranda. The full briefs have not yet been independently reviewed, so their precise arguments should not be assumed.
The court's order does identify two central questions, however: how the appeals ruling affects the Kentucky case and whether new federal rules could change the legal analysis.
The filings form part of United States v. Commonwealth of Kentucky, a case brought by the CFTC and the federal government in June 2026. The agency wants to prevent Kentucky from enforcing state gambling laws against exchanges registered with the CFTC.
The dispute between Kentucky and the CFTC centers on who has authority over sports event contracts offered by federally registered prediction market exchanges.
Kentucky argues that sports event contracts offered by prediction market apps such as Kalshi amount to unlicensed sports wagering and should fall under state gambling laws. The state previously took enforcement action against prediction market operators and introduced a special transaction fee affecting CFTC-regulated exchanges.
The CFTC takes the opposite position, arguing that Congress gave the agency exclusive authority over commodity derivatives traded on registered exchanges, meaning state gambling laws cannot be used to shut down those federally regulated markets.
The agency filed its federal lawsuit against Kentucky on June 23, 2026, and is seeking an injunction preventing the state from enforcing its restrictions against CFTC-registered contract markets.
One important development is the Sixth Circuit's decision in Kalshi v. Schuler on September 25. The appeals court ruled that Ohio and Tennessee could apply their gambling laws to Kalshi's sports event contracts, rejecting the company's argument that federal commodities law preempted those state rules.
That decision factors in because Kentucky is within the Sixth Circuit. The federal court handling the CFTC's case must consider the appeals court's reasoning when evaluating the parties' arguments.
The Kentucky case is not simply a repeat of Schuler, however. It involves a federal challenge brought by the CFTC and the United States against Kentucky, rather than just a single platform's request to block state enforcement.
The CFTC is also working on rules intended to clarify how event contracts are treated under federal commodities law. Its recent rulemaking proposals address the definition of swaps and the treatment of event contracts based on sports, politics, culture, and weather.
The agency's position is that these contracts fall within its regulatory remit, while state regulators argue that sports-related markets can constitute gambling.
The new rules could influence future court decisions, but they do not automatically settle the Kentucky dispute.
Judge S. Chad Meredith has scheduled oral arguments for December 1, 2026, in Lexington. The hearing will address the pending motions and supplemental briefing. No ruling on the merits has been announced.
The outcome could affect how prediction market operators offer sports contracts in Kentucky and how far federal regulation extends over products that states consider sports betting.

Disclaimer: All of the information on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We do NOT accept bets of any kind. The information we provide is accurate and trustworthy to help you make better decisions. When you click or tap on a link on Dimers that leads to a third-party website that we have a commercial arrangement with (such as an online sportsbook), we may earn referral fees. Dimers does not endorse or encourage illegal or irresponsible gambling in any form. Before placing any wagers with any betting site, you must check the online gambling regulations in your jurisdiction or state, as they do vary. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, crisis counseling and referral services can be accessed by calling 1-800-MY-RESET or 1-800-GAMBLER.
Copyright © [yyyy] Dimers. All Rights Reserved. Proudly part of Cipher Sports Technology Group, 902A Broadway, Floors 6 & 7, New York, NY 10010, United States of America.