Select the sportsbooks and prediction markets you use to unlock more betting opportunities.
Casinos and sportsbooks have mostly let state regulators lead the fight against Kalshi. Not anymore.
On October 8, 2026, the American Gaming Association filed an amicus brief urging the U.S. Supreme Court to take New Jersey's case against the prediction market, its most direct move yet in a dispute that keeps splitting federal courts.
The case is Flaherty v. KalshiEX, docket No. 26-299. New Jersey's gaming regulators petitioned on September 2, months after losing 2-1 at the Third Circuit in April, which blocked the state from enforcing its gaming laws against Kalshi while the case plays out.
The AGA's brief, filed through Covington & Burling, sides with New Jersey. Its core claim is blunt. Sports event contracts are, in substance, sports bets, and Dodd-Frank was never meant to be "a nationwide gambling code," as the brief puts it.
Courts can't agree, and that's usually what gets the justices interested. The Third Circuit went Kalshi's way. Then in August, the Ninth Circuit ruled against Kalshi in its Nevada fight, and the Sixth did the same in September over Ohio and Tennessee. Same core question, opposite answers.
For anyone following sports prediction markets, that split is really the whole story, because whether a state can police these contracts currently depends a lot on which circuit it happens to sit in.
The AGA also leaned on money and sovereignty. Its members, commercial and tribal casino operators along with sportsbooks and suppliers, work in markets it says generate $53 billion a year in tax revenue, and the brief claims states have lost more than $1.5 billion in potential tax revenue since prediction markets began offering sports contracts. Age limits and responsible-gaming rules also come up.
The AGA is far from alone. Its brief hit the docket the same day as filings from the NFL, the Casino Association of New Jersey, 145 tribes and former CFTC chairman Gary Gensler, and a day earlier Ohio and 38 other states, plus D.C., filed one of their own. Count it all up, and the docket showed eleven amicus briefs by the close of October 8, the earliest from the National Council of Legislators from Gaming States back on September 22.
Sports are only one part of it, though. Prediction markets cover topics covering economics, weather, culture, politics predictions, and more, but none of those markets are affected.
Kalshi asked for more time and got it, so its response is due November 9. Only then will the justices decide whether to hear the case at all, and nothing's been granted yet, which means the Third Circuit's ruling still shields Kalshi in New Jersey while two other circuits point the other way.
If you wish to take a closer look at available platforms or try trading for yourself, check out our list of prediction markets for a comprehensive overview.

Disclaimer: All of the information on this site is for entertainment purposes only. We do NOT accept bets of any kind. The information we provide is accurate and trustworthy to help you make better decisions. When you click or tap on a link on Dimers that leads to a third-party website that we have a commercial arrangement with (such as an online sportsbook), we may earn referral fees. Dimers does not endorse or encourage illegal or irresponsible gambling in any form. Before placing any wagers with any betting site, you must check the online gambling regulations in your jurisdiction or state, as they do vary. If you or someone you know has a gambling problem, crisis counseling and referral services can be accessed by calling 1-800-MY-RESET or 1-800-GAMBLER.
Copyright © [yyyy] Dimers. All Rights Reserved. Proudly part of Cipher Sports Technology Group, 902A Broadway, Floors 6 & 7, New York, NY 10010, United States of America.